From £25,0008

Is Peugeot’s rakish new Mondeo rival as good to drive as it is to look at - and has it done enough to best competitor saloons?

Has Europe’s family car market gone full circle? How long will it be, given the premium-brand-centric, SUV-mad phase in which we find ourselves, before a well-designed, mid-sized, mid-market saloon starts like the Peugeot 508 to look like the smart, desirable option again?

The arrival of cars such as the Volkswagen Arteon and Kia Stinger suggests the idea might have appeared a while ago in one or two of the industry’s product-planning crystal balls – and it’s now becoming manifest.

Peugeot’s new front-end graphic gets its production debut here. Long vertical elements framing the front end appear on all cars, but for the full LED effect you need upper-level GT Line or GT trim

This week’s road test subject is a case in point. The second-generation Peugeot 508 comes from a European brand with plenty of pedigree for fine-handling, mid-sized, midmarket saloons. The 405 and 406 delivered alternative French design appeal and critically acclaimed dynamics, while the earlier and larger 504 and 505 were often given ‘world-class’ billing among saloons of a similar price.

Peugeot wouldn’t be Peugeot if hadn’t come back to a car like this, having turned its hand to SUVs, crossovers and Peugeot commercial vehicles these past few years.

When the covers came off the 508 at Geneva this year, it became evident that the conservative design of its 2010-2018 Peugeot 508 predecessor wasn’t being repeated. Like many rivals, Peugeot has seen the way the wind has blown for modern saloon design and has stirred a welcome dose of eye-catching, curvaceous style into the 508’s recipe. And having always offered three-box saloons with conventional boots, it has acknowledged modern preferences in another way by switching to a hatchback bodystyle.

Back to top

 

DESIGN & STYLING

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - hero side

So comprehensive are Peugeot’s changes that this latest 508 and its big-boned predecessor can barely be described as being related. The rear light bar is borrowed from the brand’s Instinct shooting brake concept, while the LED ‘tusks’ in the front bumper are cutting-edge at this price.

There are frameless doors, chrome exhaust tips and wheels that properly fill their arches, and the silhouette is that of a “two-and-a-half-box fastback”, as design director Gilles Vidal puts it. If you appreciate the look of Audi’s Audi A5 Sportback, your eyes will be drawn to the 508 – and not simply because of the complex rear three-quarter panels that necessitated stamping methods generally the preserve of sports cars.

The last Peugeot saloon to have a model badge on its bonnet? The 504, but it was a habit running a long way further back for the marque than the late 1960s

Despite its D-segment sensibilities, the 508 is conveniently sized, being some 80mm shorter and 51mm lower than before and much smaller of footprint than either the Ford Mondeo or Skoda Superb. The payoff is a tighter turning circle than that of most family hatches, despite the athletic proportions.

The new car is now 70kg lighter on average, partly due to a new steel monocoque but mainly because it’s built on the stiffer EMP2 platform that was developed at colossal expense and is shared with the Peugeot 3008 and Peugeot 5008 crossovers. Giving the old PF3 underpinnings the boot also bodes well for handling.

Our test car uses the PSA Group’s 2.0-litre four-cylinder turbo diesel, which drives the front wheels through an eight-speed automatic gearbox. It’s offered with either 161bhp or 174bhp, while a 1.5-litre diesel, available in manual only, will backstop the line-up with 129bhp and CO2 emissions of just 98g/km.

A high proportion of fleet sales means as few as one in 10 508s are expected to drink petrol, but those cars will do so courtesy of a 1.6-litre four-pot turbo with 178bhp or 221bhp. If the range sounds conservative, Peugeot says this platform was designed for versatility and that mild- and plug-in hybrid variants – the latter with an electrically driven rear axle – will arrive next year with no adverse effect on cabin or the admittedly modest boot capacity.

In chassis terms, there are no surprises here. The front axle is suspended by MacPherson struts while the rear uses a multi-link design. Adaptive dampers with modes ranging from Eco to Sport are standard issue on top-of-the-line GT models, but the rank and file make do with a passive set-up. Our GT test car rides on 19in wheels with modest 235/40 tyres at each corner.

INTERIOR

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - cabin

The same defining neat sense of compactness that adds to the appeal of the 508’s exterior comes across quite plainly as you acclimatise to the car’s cabin. There isn’t the sheer width you’ll find in some cars in this class, though – the result being that while the 508 seems to sit within the lane of a typical UK A-road with a bit of space to breathe, it’s probably not a car in which to try to put three child seats across the back bench or in which to seat three adults in the rear.

Adults occupying the outer rear chairs won’t find masses of head and knee room, either, although there will be plenty for a typical family of four. The Peugeot’s boot, meanwhile, is about 10% to 20% smaller than you might find elsewhere for your money, although it’s still on a par with the saloon class average for volume.

Never liked the i-Cockpit control philosophy, but it bothers me much less here than it has elsewhere. Perhaps it’s because you sit lower than in a hatch or SUV – or perhaps Peugeot has got better at tuning the car to accommodate it

Anyone who has driven one of Peugeot’s latest generation of cars – anything since the Peugeot 3008 of 2016 – will recognise the same kind of materially rich, nicely alternative ambience in here. There is, though, perhaps a little bit too much glossy black plastic on the 508’s centre stack and transmission tunnel, and a few too many harder, cheaper plastic mouldings up high and down low around the cabin, to convince you that you’re sitting in something that’s as expensively hewn as an Audi, Mercedes-Benz or Volkswagen.

Still, Peugeot makes up for that deficiency by delivering a more stylish, interesting interior than you’ll find from at least some of those brands – although not, admittedly, one of such dutiful attention to detail. The 508’s seats aren’t the most comfortable you might have sat in, with seat cushions that, when extended, leave a bothersome gap under your thighs.

The car’s i-Cockpit control layout, with its high-mounted digital dials and necessarily low-slung steering wheel, won’t suit everyone – although it bothered us much less here than it has in other Peugeots. Meanwhile, the car’s line of ‘piano key’ infotainment shortcut buttons robs you of the one handy place where you might have rested an extended left arm while operating that all-important central touchscreen display.

Our GT-specification test car came with very pleasant full-grain leather (you get only part-leather as standard on a mid-spec model). On balance, however, the 508’s inviting and alternatively executed cabin can still be considered a selling point for the car.

The 12.3in digital instrument display is different from many in that you look at it over the top of the steering wheel rather than through the orbit of it. In other Peugeots, we’ve struggled with that notion, having to accept putting the wheel at an unnaturally low angle to make the dials fully visible. In the 508, most testers said they could see the instruments better.

The car’s instrument dial is customisable too – although it’s not like the one on an Audi TT, which has to do the usual job of the infotainment display as well. You get an 8.0in central touchscreen display on entry-level cars, rising to a 10.0in ‘high-definition’ one with Allure trim and upwards and as fitted to our car.

Piano key menu buttons make the central touchscreen easier than it might be to navigate, and the display looks crisp and attractive, rendering navigation mapping more clearly than we’ve seen in other Peugeots.

You have to go all the way to GT trim level to get Peugeot’s Focal premium audio system, though – and the system isn’t so good that it would be worth the outlay on its own.

ENGINES & PERFORMANCE

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - engine

Selecting Sport via the 508’s centre console-mounted switch elicits a handful of changes to its character. In addition to a moderately more responsive throttle and meatier steering, the synthesised engine note sounds like it’s being broadcast in the cabin in stereo, or at least as though it has been double-tracked.

Were it a particularly euphonious soundtrack, this would be a welcome change; however, given the grumbly, diesely timbre of the 508’s BlueHDi motor, the increase in volume isn’t a particularly welcome one, and it ends up coming across as a flawed attempt at making the engine sound bigger and richer than it is. At maximum revs in fourth gear, our sound gear recorded cabin noise at 74dB; by comparison, the Volvo V60’s D4 engine – which we criticised for being overly vocal – measured 73dB.

Slimline 508 sits more comfortably in its lane than three adults at the back might. Still, good road manners mean rear passengers shouldn’t be unduly inconvenienced

Still, straight-line performance is agreeable for a car in this class. A timed 0-60mph run of 8.8sec – compromised, perhaps, by a scrabble for traction off the line – is roughly par for the course, if a little behind Peugeot’s 8.3sec 0-62mph claim. The 187bhp Audi A4 TDI tested in 2015 did the same run in 8.4sec, while the 2012 BMW 320d managed 7.6sec.

However, with similar torque (295lb ft for the Audi and 280lb ft for the BMW), the Germans bettered the 508 from 30mph to 70mph – a more representative benchmark for real-world accelerative potency – by considerable margins. While the Peugeot took 8.5sec, the A4 managed 7.2sec and the 320d needed 7.4sec.

Repeating the same run while locked in fourth gear – an indicator of an engine’s flexibility – took 9.7sec in the Peugeot, placing it between the Audi (8.2sec) and the BMW (10.8sec).

The manner in which this acceleration is delivered is generally smooth, although if you stray too far past 4000rpm, the diesel runs out of breath. One tester also commented on an apparent tendency for the eight-speed ’box to hold on to its gears for slightly longer than necessary above this point – a factor that could have contributed to the 508’s failure to meet or better its manufacturer’s 0-62mph claims.

Out on the road, the transmission goes about swapping cogs in a generally smooth and unintrusive way. The only times when a shade of indecisiveness was detected were at lower speeds, where there could be a degree of shunt when pulling away. On track, though, things weren’t so slick.

RIDE & HANDLING

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - cornering front

The 508 composes itself with fluency and subtlety on undulating roads. Vertical body control over crests is tight, while the compression that follows is cushioned and progressive. The fact that the primary ride is so tidy, however, makes a sometimes questionable secondary ride that much more of a shame.

Our 19in-alloy-equipped 508 carried with it a tendency to emphasise the severity of ruts and bumps on more threadbare sections of road. Imperfections you sense may not have been quite so intrusive in rival D-segment saloons made their presence felt.

I’ve driven the 508 on both 19in and 18in alloys, and on the smaller rim the improvement in secondary ride was only marginal

While not doing so in a bone-shattering fashion by any means, it was with enough sharpness to leave a cloud of doubt over the 508’s otherwise impressive manners.

Comfort mode helps to mute these disturbances to a degree, but not quite to the extent where you’re totally isolated from shudders and vibrations. The 508 seems happiest on comparatively smooth motorways, where those intrusions are at their most infrequent and you can make the most of its fluid primary ride.

At three full turns from lock to lock, the gearing of the 508’s steering rack errs on the slower side, and the diminutive wheel – now a signature trait of Peugeot interiors – does take some getting used to. Around town, there’s very little in the way of weight or feel here, although once you add pace it gains some reassuring heft if no additional propensity for communication.

It takes about a quarter of a turn of the wheel for the 508’s front end to respond with proper enthusiasm, but when it bites it does so with enough in the way of tenacity to instil confidence when pressing on. Roll around the lateral axis is progressive and well managed, too, while mid-corner directional changes don’t lead to any great loss of composure. Sport mode tightens things up even further, although not to the extent that you’d label the 508 an outstandingly exciting car to thread along a challenging or inviting section of B-road.

Road works prevented us from properly pushing the 508 around Millbrook’s Hill Route but, on the stretches where it was safe to do so, the numerous steep ascents unearthed a degree of indecisiveness in the Peugeot’s eight-speed transmission.

The gearbox was generally smooth and effective under regular driving conditions. However, when driven in anger on a stretch of Tarmac as variable in gradient as this, the ’box seemed a touch overwhelmed. Progress out of a corner and up an ascent was hampered by a noticeable delay as it searched for a suitable ratio.

That said, the presence of a manual mode does allow for a greater degree of control to be wielded, but as this is accessed via a dedicated drive mode, you’ll have to forgo the tighter body control and weightier steering that comes in Sport mode.

MPG & RUNNING COSTS

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - hero front

Peugeot’s pricing for the 508 certainly looks punchy. A mid-spec 1.5-litre diesel costs 10% more than an equivalent Volkswagen Passat, 15% more than a like-for-like Ford Mondeo and some 20% more expensive than a like-for-like Vauxhall Insignia.

Peugeot’s claim is that its limited ambitions on UK sales volume will come into play to make monthly finance deals more competitive.

The 508 is forecast to perform relatively strongly in terms of depreciation. It betters the VW Passat, but still loses out to the Audi A5

Even so, with no manufacturer support in place for finance on the car, the same lower-mid-spec 508 1.5 BlueHDi Allure would currently cost you £320 a month on a typical five-year main-dealer PCP deal, while a like-for-like Passat would currently cost closer to £250. Audi A5 Sportback ownership on the same terms starts at about £360.

This isn’t a car that’s going to have strong appeal on value-for-money terms, then. But where running costs are concerned, the car’s CO2 emissions are certainly low enough to take the sting out of its highish list price for a company car tax payer.

On our touring fuel economy test, our car returned 52mpg, which beats what we produced from the current Audi A4 2.0 TDI in 2015 (49.6mpg) and from current Passat 2.0 TDI tested the same year (51.6mpg). With what ought to be a couple of even more frugal diesel options below our test car in the range, that’s an impressive showing.

 

VERDICT

Peugeot 508 2018 road test review - hero static

Success in the compact saloon class was never going to come easy. A serious breadth of ability is crucial in achieving critical acclaim in a segment home to the Jaguar XE, Alfa Romeo Giulia and BMW 3 Series – all cars that combine abundant driver appeal, desirability and usability to great effect.

Yet while the 508 ticks some of those boxes, it’s not quite the all-rounder it needs to be to get the nod over and above its rivals. It is sharply dressed and visually alluring but is hampered by a tight second row. The i-Cockpit cabin is more appealing than it has ever been but is marred slightly by materials that aren’t as rich as they first appear to be. And while the 508 is a decently agile and largely composed steer, it isn’t quite as engaging as those predominantly rear-driven cars at the business end of our top five.

Stylish and likeable but lacking the polish of more premium rivals

The 508 is certainly a job well done for Peugeot, though, and it’s a car we’d have no qualms about recommending to someone looking for an alternative, contemporary French take on a well-worn – and predominantly German – saloon car theme.

 

Peugeot 508 First drives