9

Mini splits the difference between Cooper S and John Cooper Works, and what a revelation it is

The market for the go-faster Mini has become somewhat muddled and fragmented since the arrival, in 2015, of the top-of-the-current-series-production-pile John Cooper Works.

Since then, we’ve had the ultra-low-volume stripped-out 228bhp John Cooper Works Challenge limited edition, complete with adjustable suspension, Cup tyres and £32k price.

2018 should be a bumper one, with the new Yaris GRMN, Fiesta ST, Polo GTI and others. I’d bet this Mini remains in our class top five, though

Then the slightly less rare but still limited Cooper S 210 Challenge Edition, built to celebrate the return of the Mini Challenge racing formula.

And finally, last year, the Cooper S Works 210: a permanent addition to the factory range that copied the mechanical recipe of the 210 Challenge Edition but was available with less lavish interior equipment and at a lower showroom price.

Oh, and don’t forget the John Cooper Works GP concept, which we saw a couple of months ago at the Frankfurt motor show; not that you’re likely to, given the extravagant scoops and aerofoils it had.

Anyone due to replace a Cooper S or JCW over the past year or two may have been waiting for his or her head to stop spinning.

Now, though, things may have calmed down. The Cooper S Works 210 has clearly been doing well enough for the past 12 months to justify Mini’s decision to make it a permanent addition to the showroom range, and that’s why the firm has just made the car available as a convertible and a five-door, as well as the classic Mini three-door.

Back to top

It’s an opportune time, then, to find out what this halfway house between the amusing if slightly lukewarm Cooper S and the full-fat yet straight-laced JCW is all about. The car is UK market only and fitted with the key mechanicals that lift it beyond Cooper S spec not at the factory but at the dealer.

Can a makeover like that really result in a meaningful difference to the pace and idiosyncratic flavour of this effervescent little driver’s car? And is it better or worse than the Cooper S or JCW?

What car new buying red 236

DESIGN & STYLING

Mini Cooper S Works 210 front end

The ingredients that turn a Cooper S into a Works 210 split neatly into two categories: those that are fitted at the factory and those that are added or replaced by your Mini dealer.

The factory items setting the car apart from a standard Cooper S outwardly are the 17in Track Spoke alloy wheels finished in gloss black, and Mini’s John Cooper Works aero kit, which consists of more aggressive front and rear valances than the standard Cooper S gets, as well as a split-level roof spoiler.

Mini’s noisy Track mode on the active exhaust is certainly loud enough to attract attention of both the wanted and unwanted varieties

The aero kit has been available as part of the John Cooper Works upgrade catalogue for a while, of course, and the wheels are just an official Cooper S option.

Nothing special or new, you might say.

You also get white indicator lenses as standard on your S Works 210, as well as John Cooper Works sill plates and ‘Works 210’ pillar badges.

When your car gets to the dealer, though, it’s fitted with Mini’s Works 210 Enhanced upgrade kit. This consists of a software reflash for the engine control system that boosts peak power from the 2.0-litre turbocharged petrol motor from 189bhp to 207bhp, and torque from a nominal 207lb ft to 221lb ft.

A Cooper S can produce that much torque through its temporary overboost function, but the Works 210 makes it without such caveat. And that puts this car on an almost dead-level footing for potency with its closest rivals from Peugeot and DS, and much closer to Ford’s outgoing Mountune-fettled Fiesta ST.

The Works 210 also gets an active exhaust system (dealer fitted and controlled by a Bluetooth remote), which features a bypass for the silencer that makes for a freer-flowing passage of air, less back pressure and far noisier performance.

For what it’s worth, Mini suggests you restrict use of the system’s angry mode to track sessions only.

There are no material changes to the Mini’s running chassis for the Works 210, so you get all-independent suspension with passive dampers, which can be upgraded to include Mini’s Variable Damper Control adaptive shocks for £375 or to a passive sport suspension set-up for £150. Our car had neither upgrade.

You can pick wheels as large as an 18in rim of 7.5J width, but it’s worth bearing in mind that one of the optional sets of 18s comes exclusively on run-flat tyres. (Run-flats are optional with most other rims.)

There’s little reason to expect any of that to save mass on the car – and in our test car’s case, it certainly didn’t.

The Cooper S three-door we tested in 2014 came in at 1265kg on the scales and the Works 210 tipped them 90kg heavier. But some of that difference may be down to the fact that the two cars were weighed on different apparatus and probably with slightly varying fuel levels.

INTERIOR

Mini Cooper S Works 210 interior

Now that the model range is once again fully filled out with Mini Clubman pseudo-estate, Mini Countryman crossover, Mini Convertible and five-door models, there is a Mini for many a differing owner and daily usage requirement; and yet none appealed more to our testing panel than the most authentic compact three-door hatchback.

But although this F56-generation car is a notably more accommodating than its direct forebear, it’s a far cry from being practical by wider supermini-class standards, with rear seats that are usable for small adults and children only, and probably only occasionally at that (and only if you’re prepared to sacrifice some front-row leg room), and a smaller-than-average boot.

JCW-branded twin exhaust is an active system that also appeared on the JCW Challenge and 210 Challenge Edition limited-series models

So the three-door Mini remains that bit less usable than most superminis.

Even so, there’s generous space for occupants in the front. You sit lower and more recumbent than you might be in most small hatchbacks, with your legs fully outstretched if you want. Uniquely in the class, the Mini will even allow a 6ft 3in driver enough space to adopt a straight-legged position with good support under your thighs, while leaving your knees and shins well clear of the surrounding door and centre console mouldings – with a good 3in of head room to spare, too.

There are no changes to report to the Cooper S’s interior elsewhere. You find a familiar list of features to like as a result: cabin mouldings, fittings and trim materials that almost all confirm to a high standard on perceived quality; a good-sized, good-looking and feature-rich (optional) widescreen infotainment set-up; and plenty of useful cabin storage.

The annoyances are familiar, too: an unnecessarily small set of instruments (with a rev counter that’s particularly small and hard to read); and a centre armrest that’s in the way of the manual handbrake when it’s down and in the way of your gearshifting elbow when it’s up.

Apart from those few bugbears, though, this is a fine cabin for a hot supermini. It puts you in an uncommonly good driving position and it’s relatively rich and pleasant to spend time in, with many racier trim garnishes than our test car had all available on Mini’s options list for those who want them.

It may be surprising to find a £22,000 supermini on sale in 2017 that comes without a colour infotainment system or a factory navigation system as standard, but that’s the bubble in which Mini exists.

It’s one where customers are not only expected to stump up for them but also probably used to the idea. You get a DAB radio as standard, but if you want even the smaller-screened Mini Navigation system, you have to pay £595 for it.

Our test car had Mini’s 8.8in widescreen Navigation XL system, which is one of the best infotainment set-ups available in any supermini.

As part of the Media Pack, you get Connected XL, through which you can access a wide range of smartphone-enabled app-based connected services such as Spotify music streaming. For now, Apple CarPlay smartphone mirroring is available on only the Countryman and Clubman.

ENGINES & PERFORMANCE

2.0-litre Mini Cooper S Works 210 petrol engine

Anyone wondering exactly how much difference an extra 18bhp and 15lb ft makes to the Cooper S’s full-power acceleration may be a touch disappointed by what follows.

The weather was grey and greasy, albeit not technically raining, on the day of our test – and it was both warmer and dryer, three years ago, on the day we tested Mini’s F56-generation Cooper S.

Chassis gives you the confidence to snap out of the accelerator on the way into quicker bends and giggle as the car rotates beneath you

No surprises, then, that the Works 210 proved a few tenths of a second slower from rest to 60mph than our benchmark for the standard Cooper S – and very slightly slower, too, from 30mph to 70mph through the gears.

You can see the performance gain that the Works 210 delivers elsewhere in our test figures, though.

The new Mini needed 0.5sec less than the standard Cooper S to reach 100mph in spite of its weather-related poorer start; it was consistently quicker than its cheaper range-mate running in gear through the higher reaches of the rev range; and it was a few tenths quicker than the Cooper S when accelerating through every 20mph increment from 60mph to 120mph.

That’s enough to suggest that, had we been testing in like-for-like conditions, we’d have seen clockings a couple of tenths better for every main performance measure, and that would have been enough to put this car in among the quickest hot superminis on sale right now.

There’s a subjective improvement, too. The Works 210 seems to rev particularly keenly above 5000rpm and so has a better-balanced and more useful operating rev range than plenty of torque-centric four-cylinder turbo motors. It has a taut, short, well-defined manual gearshift, too, and a well-tuned brake pedal with plenty of progressive feel.

However, the car’s added pace is as nothing compared to the difference made to its audible charm by that active exhaust.

Double-press the system’s Bluetooth remote control and this Mini’s vocals are transformed from zesty yet moderate to decidedly demonstrative and naughty.

At times – particularly when the exhaust is hot after a long, hard drive – the Works 210 sounds like a beat-boxing cyborg with a talent for pyrotechnics.

The engine note riffs and growls with a synthesised, digital virtuosity when you feather the accelerator, and subsequently pops and crackles with antisocial menace on the overrun.

So this Mini isn’t just loud: it’s also characterful, dramatic and interesting to listen to.

RIDE & HANDLING

Mini Cooper S Works 210 cornering

Mini was absolutely right to leave well enough alone where the Cooper S Works 210’s suspension settings were concerned.

It could have made passive sports springs standard fit, or else fiddled with the car’s state of tune just for the sake of fiddling.

Body control is excellent. Handling response, outright grip and balance are all very good

But it resisted the temptation and has produced a car here – tested in absolutely standard specification, remember – whose handling represents the firm at its best.

To drive, the Works 210 is an eccentric, vivacious supermini that’s agile, immediate and energetic in everything it does – and compelling in plenty of ways.

But unlike other performance Minis we’ve driven, there’s a sense of well-judged equilibrium to the spring rates, damper set-up, ride fluency, grip level and rate of handling response. There’s also a truly pleasing, lively and playful sense of balance to the cornering manners that those more expensive, over-sprung, over-tyred model siblings often fail to reproduce.

Like all Minis, the Works 210 is fairly reactive in how it rides over a typical B-road, but it doesn’t ever pitch and rebound over the bumps in a discouraging way, and it quite easily maintains a cradled, settled sense of composure.

Our test car dealt with sharper edges much better than run-flat-equipped Minis we’ve tested in recent years and it had a little bit of helpful steering feel to go with the rack’s rapier pace.

You can choose between Sport, Mid and Green driving modes, the first ramping down steering assistance to a hefty but not leaden level.

The car is at its best on fairly smooth, wide, well-sighted roads where there is a little bit of space to bring its natural agility to the fore.

On those kinds of roads, our test car’s cornering attitude was more adjustable than that of most rivals and greatly involving with it. It’s a match in that respect even for Ford’s celebrated Fiesta ST. The chassis is also the darting, enticing kind that makes particularly short, exciting work of quiet roundabouts and tight motorway slip roads.

On an ever-so-slightly slippery Wednesday in November, Millbrook’s Alpine hill route felt like the perfect stage for a Mini that found plenty of grip where less sensitively set-up hot hatchbacks might have struggled.

The car launched itself gleefully into the track’s tighter hairpins. It offered plenty of off-throttle handling adjustability if you wanted it but also strong grip and stability with the electronic aids enabled.

If you opt for off-throttle adjustability, the car slides into neutrality and beyond quite quickly, but lift-off oversteer is easily tidied up through the fast-paced steering – most of the time without really needing to feed the wheel or even move your hands from quarter to three.

The car’s firm suspension didn’t exactly make short work of the transmission bumps at the beginning of the lap, but it wasn’t tripped up by them, either, declining to be deflected off line.

MPG & RUNNING COSTS

Mini Cooper S Works 210

The Mini owner saves £1600 by opting for a Works 210 instead of a John Cooper Works three-door and pays £2600 more than for a standard Cooper S, but also less than if picking the car’s various mechanical augmentations one by one out of the JCW tuning catalogue.

Comparison with the JCW factory model is of little importance anyway considering the Works 210 is a better-balanced and more appealing driver’s car.

Mini’s residuals not what they were a decade ago but still strong enough to make rivals from Renault and DS look pricey

It’s actually quite competitively priced against its rivals. At least, the base price is. At which point, of course, you have to be ready to spend another several thousand pounds on kit like a premium infotainment system, premium audio, parking sensors and the like. With the Mini’s opponents, you won’t need to spend half as much on options.

Works 210 owners will see some of their initial outlay returned over the life of their cars in the shape of better residual values than they might have otherwise experienced, but this is sure to be a relatively expensive car to own.

Insurance costs, though, could be worse: rated in group 30, the Works 210 should be cheaper to insure than a Peugeot 208 GTI, DS3 Performance or Audi S1.

What car new buying red 236

VERDICT

4.5 star Mini Cooper S Works 210

This is the best driver’s car that Mini has come up with during its current heartland-model generation.

It has the outright performance to hold its head high next to its hot supermini rivals, but also a more delicate, better-balanced and more engaging chassis than its bigger brother, the John Cooper Works.

After so many attempts, Mini unearths its hot hatch sweet spot

It’s a more rounded road car than the JCW, too, and better value. And while its engine feels potent and free-revving, it wants for nothing on audible charm, thanks to that switchable active exhaust.

Like so many modern BMW Group cars, this one is available in myriad combinations of suspension, wheel and tyre specification, but the car’s chassis works very well indeed if you keep your order simple.

This is a car with the busy, tigerish, feisty temperament that you expect from a hot Mini but no more or less grip or body control than it really needs, and handling that becomes more playfully engaging the closer you examine it.

Simply put, it seems to derive all the dynamic benefits of its diminutive size that you hope it might, without being penalised harshly in many of the ways you fear it would.

What car new buying red 236

Mini Cooper S Works 210 2017 First drives